Wednesday, 26 January 2011

Business goes on as the cuts bite

The tragic story of Riven Vincent, the mother of a severely-disabled child who told the website Mumsnet last week that she could no longer cope, drew attention to at least two fundamental issues other than her own personal circumstances.
The first was that the media onslaught was aimed squarely at the prime minister rather than the mother’s local authority, even though, technically, it was the latter’s responsibility. Indeed, the media rather buried the local authority angle since it muddied their line that it was David Cameron’s fault for promising to protect disability care services – when he met the mother during the election – and then not delivering.
This sets an uncomfortable precedent for the coalition which has striven, so far, to devolve the decision-making and the odium about cuts to councils. For while there will be many more tragic individual cases blame for their predicament looks set to be laid at the door of Number 10, not the civic centre.
Second, the case of Ms Vincent reminded the public of the huge and rising bill for children’s services, and the difficulty of containing costs, let alone reducing them, despite swingeing budget cuts.
It is appalling that families with severely-disabled children – already victims – find themselves further victimised through spending cuts. Nor will Ofsted allow any reduction in safeguarding services after the Baby Peter case.
So, what does it imply? As one county chief executive said to me: ‘When it comes to closing a branch library or protecting child safeguarding services, of course, I’ll do the latter.’ Another said to me: ‘As a county, we will become little more than an agency for safeguarding vulnerable children and adults.’ Recent council budgets announced for 2011 show them making strenuous efforts to maintain children’s services budgets or, in some cases, increase them.
The public, however, remain generally ignorant of how much of their council’s budget is swallowed up by children’s – and adult care – services. All they see are their favourite local amenities being cut from parks to libraries to community centre grants. The tragic case of Ms Vincent should focus the minds of national politicians on how children’s services can be adequately funded without laying waste to all other council services.

Wednesday, 19 January 2011

Business goes on as the cuts bite

It is right that the LGA should be bolshy about the financial settlement for local government. The sector has been stuffed, and as the full impact of the settlement percolates through departmental budgets, the reality is worse than it first appeared.
Even in the past few days on the circuit, all the chief executives can talk about is how many redundancies they are conducting and whether the first year cuts are 10%, 20% – or, as two district chiefs told me this week, 40%.
PM David Cameron’s speech to the RSA this week maintaining that public spending would be the same as 2006 earned a riposte from one district chief to me that in his council’s case, the 2011 budget took it back to 1997.
Meanwhile, because councils always do what they are told, business has to go on. So, for example, this week, SOLACE’s annual election conference was packed with anxious chiefs, because on 5 May, there is the perfect storm of not only elections in 280 English councils, but polls for the parliament in Scotland, assemblies in Wales and Northern Ireland, four mayoral elections and last, but definitely not least, the UK-wide referendum for a new voting system (subject to legislation passing).
All of this is the responsibility of council chief executives and electoral administrators, none of whom can afford any more repeats of queues at polling booths, as happened last May.
Even although turnout for the referendum is expected to be 30%, there is still the risk of students deliberately causing chaos by turning up en masse to polling stations 10 minutes before they close as part of their tuition fees protests.
Admittedly, the Government, conscious of budget cuts, is ensuring the elections are fully funded and, despite slashing public spending, is managing to find some £54m in the otherwise-empty Treasury cupboard to cover council referendum costs.
Even assuming the costs are met, councils are still grappling with severe budget cuts and reduced staffing levels, and need the headache of the referendum like a hole in the head.
But then, getting on with whatever they are asked to do in whatever circumstances and with whatever financial constrains is what councils do and what, it appears, governments expect them to do. For how long is another question.

Wednesday, 12 January 2011

The smear campaign against councils

It was inevitable that a row about whose responsibility it is for service cuts – local or central government – would surface, once the full implication of last month’s settlement on individual budgets was clear.
It was also obvious the dark arts of media spinning would come into play.
The coalition’s approach is to pass the buck to local government under the guise of localism. So all cuts are, therefore, a local issue, and ministers are mere bystanders who have devolved powers and can, therefore, not be blamed for what ensues. Fair enough. Councils back localism, accept they are having to shoulder a large burden of deficit-reduction, and agree it is up to them how they make difficult decisions about priorities.
However, it is not unreasonable to ask that ministers, in turn, practice what they preach on localism. It would even be nice to hear some praise from time to time, considering the reductions councils are being expected to bear.
In fact, what we have been seeing in the past few weeks is a drip-drip trashing of the sector through selected sympathetic media. The latest example was in a Sunday newspaper last weekend, suggesting that councils were hiking fees and charges – or what it called ‘stealth taxes’ – to pay for managers’ salaries and pensions. This followed ministerial claims that rubbish was not being collected for as much as a month over Christmas, which was hotly denied by the LGA. Then there was the usual assault on senior salaries, with ministerial complaints that only a handful of chiefs had taken pay cuts.
Personally, I believe raising fees and charges well above inflation is a bad idea for councils, poisoning relations with residents and yielding diminishing returns as it meets consumer resistance. But that is their choice. It certainly hasn’t stopped the train operators, Transport for London, energy utilities, credit card issuers, oil companies, and the chancellor from whacking above-inflation rises on the public.
Ministers should make a New Year’s resolution to let local authorities decide their own priorities – rightly or wrongly – and accept councils are grappling with the biggest funding cuts in decades, and could do with the occasional word of encouragement.

Wednesday, 15 December 2010

It’s been bad news all along

The Treasury used to soften public opinion leading up to a Budget by leaking, the previous weekend, dire predictions of tax increases and spending cuts which proved to be groundless, thus leaving the public relieved things were not worse.
In the case of the local government settlement, there has been no attempt to soften opinion. In the weeks before the Comprehensive Spending Review (CSR), there were dire predictions that local government was going to get clobbered. Sure enough, in the CSR, local government was clobbered. In the run-up to the settlement, there were more predictions that local government would get a hammering in the settlement. This week it did. You could certainly not accuse ministers of spinning. They have never bothered to disguise the fact that local government is the Aunt Sally of public spending cuts, nor deviated from their insistence from day one in power that town and county halls will bear the brunt to spare education, health and international development.
The public themselves are certainly aware that their councils are being squeezed from above. In some cases, they may even have noticed certain services are being curtailed. But, generally, the impact has yet to be truly felt. Even the national media are starting to get bored with stories about branch libraries under threat and potholes unfilled, partly because they ran the same stories the day after the CSR, when local government got its hammering then and partly because they are yet to occur in any quantity. What the media require is human interest – a tragedy, a catastrophe, blame to be apportioned, either to hapless council officials or heartless ministers who have slashed budgets.
But that is in the future and hopefully, never. For the next few weeks, councils will attempt to absorb their revenue downturns with the minimal impact on frontline services. If they can manage, it will be a super-human achievement. If not, then the library cuts and unfilled potholes will be superseded by far bigger stories of strategic service reductions – and ministers will be asking themselves whether, after all, it was a good idea to deal local government such a bad hand.
On that cheery note – a happy Christmas to you all!

Wednesday, 8 December 2010

Bill for the long term

In the revolving door that was the secretary of state’s office responsible for local government under Labour (Prescott, Byers, Prescott again, Miliband, Kelly, Blears, Denham) each new incumbent tended to regard having their own white paper as a badge of office.
The coalition in contrast appears to have decided that one local government Bill is quite enough for one Parliament. Considering that it is both unravelling 13 years of Labour policy (and in the case of scrapping the Audit Commission previous Tory policy as well) along with setting out its own stall for local government until 2015 it is hardly surprising the Localism Bill is due to run to 200 clauses. Indeed the diminutive local government minister Bob Neill joked last week at a conference that although he had a copy of the Bill on his desk he could still see over the top of it.
Actually, most of the Localism Bill’s contents have been fairly straightforward to put together and much has already been well trailed. The stumbling block which has delayed its publication to the point at which civil servants fear they might be sharing the Christmas Day turkey with Eric Pickles has been over creating directly elected mayors in the 12 English cities outside London. Big city councils do not like them. They did not like them when they were Tony Blair’s Big Idea a decade ago either. And you can be sure Eric and his team have not been shoe-horning mayors into the Bill only to see the only take-up come from shire districts.
But despite its breadth, will the Bill live up to its name? Despite their insistence on a localist agenda coalition ministers have been tempted so far to intervene on anything from council newspapers and chief executive salaries to council tax levels and fortnightly bin collections. Is Big Society an opportunity or a threat to councils? And the absence of any serious push towards Total Place or community budgeting outside the 16 pilots is disappointing considering how many savings have been identified from previous studies.
However the biggest challenge by far is implementing these changes in the midst of unprecedented cuts in public spending. That will be the real test both for the Bill and for localism.

Wednesday, 1 December 2010

A little too much of a hurry..?

As the row over the front-loading of grant cuts rumbles on to the 11th hour of the postponed financial settlement – any bets on publication, Christmas Eve at 11pm? – is this the time to feel a tad sorry for Eric Pickles?
The self-confessed ‘fat man in a hurry’ may have been perhaps a little too hasty when presenting himself before the Star Chamber, back in the autumn. When dealing with the Treasury, it is always wise to a) read the small print on any deal before signing, and b) check your pockets before leaving. These people are past masters at relieving Cabinet ministers of large amounts of cash without them even noticing.
The fact is, Eric has done a sterling job for his coalition and deserves a warming brandy at Chequers from the boss on Christmas Day for the way he volunteered local government for the lion’s share of the cuts in the Spending Review. His Cabinet colleagues, particularly health, the Department for International Development and education, will doubtless have slapped him on the back, relieved that his sacrifice has spared their own.
And to be fair to Eric, he will have returned from his Star Chamber encounter feeling that, while the local government settlement was tough, it was no more than expected by the sector itself – and, indeed, there was the benefit of an extra £1bn for councils to tackle adult care on top.
The problem is the front-loading element of the cuts which Eric and his colleagues now realise is rapidly becoming a large elephant trap, opening out before them. Unfortunately, unlike shoppers buying their Christmas gifts, there is no cooling-off period with the Treasury. The deal has been made and Eric is stuck with it.
He may thrash about, asking councils to look down the backs of their sofas for cash reserves, but as things stand, the front-loading is set to be a massive headache. And just when the bad press starts about library closures, old folk in unheated homes, streetlights turned off and roads pockmarked with holes, Eric will find his Cabinet colleagues are suddenly nowhere to be seen. It’s a brutal world, politics.

Wednesday, 24 November 2010

A re-appraisal or a U-turn

Like nature, politics abhors a vacuum. As Ed Miliband is finding, appearing to be doing very little is a sure way of being accused of lacking leadership. The important part of a politician’s job spec is to engage in frenetic activity.
Coalition ministers have certainly been putting this into practice. The last few months have seen a dizzying succession of policy announcements, White Papers and Whitehall restructuring. The Tory conference fringe last month was a hotbed of packed workshops and eager ministerial speakers as the policy pointy-heads feverishly mapped out their plans for the New Age.
So it is perhaps unsurprising that in this bedlam of activity policy has sometimes been made on the hoof or without sufficient thought to the law of unintended consequences (LUC). Last week’s ‘leak’ of plans to fund schools through a new quango caused such an uproar ministers had to backtrack. Over at the CLG, changes to social housing tenancies have quietly contained a get-out clause in case the policy leads to LUC. The abolition of the Audit Commission is going to have huge ramifications for the council audit function.
And ministers are now taking another look at the way council grant cuts have been front-loaded into the first year, hinting that when the settlement appears in a fortnight there could well be flexibilities to spread the pain. Under the Spending Review plans, the gentlest year for cuts is in 2013/14 at 0.8% – nothing to do with county elections of course – compared with a tough 8.4% (and the rest) next year.
There are of course councils who believe it is better to get the pain over and done with rather than drag it out. But it is also clear that swingeing cuts will be on the cards with services slashed, libraries closed, street lights turned off etc and ministers can see themselves on the receiving end of public opprobrium.
Some may call this rethink it a U-turn, others a sensible reappraisal of a complex brief. It is certainly better to make changes before rather than after new policies have been enshrined in law. But hyperactive ministers may also want to ensure that in their eagerness to be pro-active they do not store up problems for themselves in the future when the chickens come home to roost.